"Kershaw is a legend, but McCutchen is not, right?" U.S. media delivered a sharp response to criticism from Pittsburgh fans.
Clayton Kershaw (Dodgers) was selected as the 'Legend Pick' for the Major League Baseball All-Star Game, prompting some Pittsburgh fans to strongly oppose the exclusion of Andrew McCutchen. However, the perspective of local experts remains calm. Following ESPN and MLB Network, U.S. sports media FanSided remarked, "Pittsburgh fans are making ridiculous claims right now."
Kershaw recently achieved a remarkable record of 3,000 strikeouts, earning a spot on the National League All-Star roster as a 'Legend Pick' selected directly by Commissioner Rob Manfred. This is the third selection as part of 'career recognition,' following Miguel Cabrera (Detroit) and Albert Pujols (St. Louis) in 2022.
However, some Pittsburgh fans criticized the MLB front office, saying, "Why is Kershaw accepted but not McCutchen?" In response, FanSided firmly rebutted, "This is an absurd comparison."
First, according to the collective bargaining agreement (CBA), only one 'Legend Pick' can be selected per league. Since both Kershaw and McCutchen are in the National League, only one can be chosen.
Second, even in a simple comparison, Kershaw is ahead. Kershaw has an earned run average (ERA) of 3.38 and an ERA+ of 118 (18% above the league average) this season. In contrast, McCutchen remains at an OPS+ of 102 and is primarily used as a designated hitter.
Third, there is a clear difference in career status. While McCutchen is an iconic player for Pittsburgh and has a history of winning the MVP award, Kershaw is a pitcher who is virtually guaranteed induction into the Hall of Fame. The 3,000 strikeouts is a timeless record and is widely regarded as a fitting choice for the commissioner's special All-Star nomination.
FanSided emphasized, "A player like McCutchen may come along again, but a pitcher like Kershaw is unlikely to be seen again. The two are not in the same league. The comparison itself is invalid."
In conclusion, the controversy over this 'Legend Pick' is more of an incident stemming from excessive fan sentiment that overlooks the essential nature of the event, which is to honor the careers of star players within MLB.
[OSEN]